ISSN 2083-6473
ISSN 2083-6481 (electronic version)




Associate Editor
Prof. Tomasz Neumann

Published by
TransNav, Faculty of Navigation
Gdynia Maritime University
3, John Paul II Avenue
81-345 Gdynia, POLAND
www http://www.transnav.eu
e-mail transnav@umg.edu.pl
A Modified HEART – 4M Method with TOPSIS for Analyzing Indonesia Collision Accidents
ABSTRACT: Human error is recognized as the most common factor that causes maritime accidents. The human error assessment and reduction technique (HEART) is a human reliability assessment (HRA) that has been widely applied in various industries. Furthermore, the HEART – 4M method has been proposed to assess maritime accidents. The HEART – 4M method can clearly define the relationship between man, machine, media, and management factors and the human error. However, the calculation process to determine the weight of every selected error-producing condition (EPC) suffers from the uncertainty of the assessor's estimation in practical applications, which may affect the objectivity of its result. In this study, a modification of the HEART – 4M method with the technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS) is proposed. TOPSIS is a multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) tool. This study aims to develop the HEART – 4M method to make it more comprehensive and objective when assessing maritime accidents. First, the parameter of the generic task is determined as in the conventional HEART method. Second, the causal factors are converted to the suitable EPC – 4M, and there are four classification factors for the 38 standard EPCs, which are divided into man, machine, media, and management factors. Third, the TOPSIS is applied to handle the problems of interdependencies and interaction among EPC – 4M and the uncertainty that exists in the assessor´s judgment. The proportion effect of each EPC – 4M is determined through TOPSIS by considering the correlation among EPC – 4M. Finally, thirteen collision data obtained from the National Transportation and Safety Committee of Indonesia are assessed to apply the proposed method.
Akyuz, Emre and Metin Celik. 2015. “A Methodological Extension to Human Reliability Analysis for Cargo Tank Cleaning Operation on Board Chemical Tanker Ships.” Safety Science 75:146–55. - doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2015.02.008
Akyuz, Emre, Metin Celik, and Selcuk Cebi. 2016. “A Phase of Comprehensive Research to Determine Marine-Specific EPC Values in Human Error Assessment and Reduction Technique.” Safety Science 87:63–75. - doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2016.03.013
Bowo, Ludfi Pratiwi and Masao Furusho. 2019a. “Usability of Human Error Assessment and Reduction Technique with a 4M Framework (HEART-4M) - A Case Study on Ship Grounding Accidents.” Journal of ETA Maritime Science 7(4):0. - doi:10.5505/jems.2019.54775
Bowo, Ludfi Pratiwi and Masao Furusho. 2019b. “Usability of Human Error Assessment and Reduction Technique with a 4M Framework (HEART–4M) – A Case Study on Ship Grounding Accidents.” Journal of ETA Maritime Science 7(October):266–79. - doi:10.5505/jems.2019.54775
Bowo, Ludfi Pratiwi, Ramdhani Eka Prilana, and Masao Furusho. 2019. “A Hybrid Methodology for Maritime Accident Analysis: The Case of Ship Collision.” - doi:10.1115/OMAE2019-96663
Casamirra, M., F. Castiglia, M. Giardina, and E. Tomarchio. 2009. “Fuzzy Modelling of HEART Methodology: Application in Safety Analyses of Accidental Exposure in Irradiation Plants.” Radiation Effects and Defects in Solids 164(5–6):291–96. - doi:10.1080/10420150902805153
Castiglia, F. and M. Giardina. 2011. “Fuzzy Risk Analysis of a Modern γ-Ray Industrial Irradiator.” Health Physics 100(6):622–31. - doi:10.1097/HP.0b013e31820153eb
Castiglia, F. and M. Giardina. 2013. “Analysis of Operator Human Errors in Hydrogen Refuelling Stations: Comparison between Human Rate Assessment Techniques.” International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 38(2):1166–76. - doi:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2012.10.092
Castiglia, Francesco, Mariarosa Giardina, and Elio Tomarchio. 2015. “THERP and HEART Integrated Methodology for Human Error Assessment.” Radiation Physics and Chemistry 116:262–66. - doi:10.1016/j.radphyschem.2014.12.012
Deacon, T., P. R. Amyotte, F. I. Khan, and S. Mackinnon. 2013. “A Framework for Human Error Analysis of Offshore Evacuations.” Safety Science 51(1):319–27. - doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2012.07.005
Dsouza, Ninochka and Lixuan Lu. 2017. “A Literature Review on Human Reliability Analysis Techniques Applied for Probabilistic Risk Assessment in the Nuclear Industry BT - Advances in Human Factors in Energy: Oil, Gas, Nuclear and Electric Power Industries.” Pp. 41–54 in, edited by S. M. Cetiner, P. Fechtelkotter, and M. Legatt. Cham: Springer International Publishing. - doi:10.1007/978-3-319-41950-3_4
EMSA. 2019. Annual Overview of Marine Casualties and Incidents 2019.
Gibson, W., A. Mills, S. Smith, and B. Kirwan. 2013. Railway Action Reliability Assessment, a Railway-Specific Approach to Human Error Quantification. - doi:10.1201/b13827-89
Graziano, A., A. P. Teixeira, and C. Guedes Soares. 2016. “Classification of Human Errors in Grounding and Collision Accidents Using the TRACEr Taxonomy.” Safety Science 86:245–57. - doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2016.02.026
Hetherington, Catherine, Rhona Flin, and Kathryn Mearns. 2006. “Safety in Shipping: The Human Element.” Journal of Safety Research 37(4):401–11. - doi:10.1016/j.jsr.2006.04.007
Hwang, Ching-Lai and Kwangsun Yoon. 1981. “Multiple Attribute Decision Making: Methods and Applications.” Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg.
Kirwan, B. 1996. “The Validation of Three Human Reliability Quantification Techniques - THERP, HEART and JHEDI: Part 1 - Technique Descriptions and Validation Issues.” Applied Ergonomics 27(6):359–73. - doi:10.1016/S0003-6870(96)00044-0
Kirwan, B. and W. Gibson. 2009. “Controller Action Reliability Assessment ( CARA ) CARA User Manual.” (August):1–70.
Kokotos, Dimitrios X. and Dionisios S. Linardatos. 2011. “An Application of Data Mining Tools for the Study of Shipping Safety in Restricted Waters.” Safety Science 49(2):192–97. - doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2010.07.015
Krohling, Renato A. and André G. C. Pacheco. 2015. “A-TOPSIS - An Approach Based on TOPSIS for Ranking Evolutionary Algorithms.” Procedia Computer Science 55(Itqm):308–17. - doi:10.1016/j.procs.2015.07.054
Lee, Joohee and Hyun Chung. 2018. “A New Methodology for Accident Analysis with Human and System Interaction Based on FRAM: Case Studies in Maritime Domain.” Safety Science 109(May):57–66. - doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2018.05.011
Maniram Kumar, A., Sivaprakasam Rajakarunakaran, and V. Arumuga Prabhu. 2017. “Application of Fuzzy HEART and Expert Elicitation for Quantifying Human Error Probabilities in LPG Refuelling Station.” Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries 48:186–98. - doi:10.1016/j.jlp.2017.04.021
Olson, D. L. 2004. “Comparison of Weights in TOPSIS Models.” Mathematical and Computer Modelling 40(7–8):721–27. - doi:10.1016/j.mcm.2004.10.003
Park, Jooyoung, Awwal Mohammed Arigi, and Jonghyun Kim. 2019. “Treatment of Human and Organizational Factors for Multi-Unit HRA: Application of SPAR-H Method.” Annals of Nuclear Energy 132:656–78. - doi:10.1016/j.anucene.2019.06.053
Saaty, Thomas L. 1985. “Axiomatization of the Analytic Hierarchy Process.” 91–108. - doi:10.1007/978-3-642-46536-9_4
Saaty, Thomas L. 1994. “How to Make a Decision: The Analytic Hierarchy Process.” Interfaces 26(4):19–43. - doi:10.1287/inte.24.6.19
Soares, C. Guedes and A. P. Teixeira. 2001. “Risk Assessment in Maritime Transportation.” Reliability Engineering and System Safety 74(3):299–309. - doi:10.1016/S0951-8320(01)00104-1
Sotiralis, P., N. P. Ventikos, R. Hamann, P. Golyshev, and A. P. Teixeira. 2016. “Incorporation of Human Factors into Ship Collision Risk Models Focusing on Human Centred Design Aspects.” Reliability Engineering and System Safety 156:210–27. - doi:10.1016/j.ress.2016.08.007
Tzannatos, Ernestos and Dimitris Kokotos. 2009. “Analysis of Accidents in Greek Shipping during the Pre- and Post-ISM Period.” Marine Policy 33(4):679–84. - doi:10.1016/j.marpol.2009.01.006
Wang, Weizhong, Xinwang Liu, and Yong Qin. 2018a. “A Modified HEART Method with FANP for Human Error Assessment in High-Speed Railway Dispatching Tasks.” International Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 67(September 2017):242–58. - doi:10.1016/j.ergon.2018.06.002
Williams, J. C. 1988. “A Data-Based Method for Assessing and Reducing Human Error to Improve Operational Performance.” Pp. 436–50 in Conference Record for 1988 IEEE Fourth Conference on Human Factors and Power Plants,.
Citation note:
Bowo L.P., Prilana R.E., Furusho M.: A Modified HEART – 4M Method with TOPSIS for Analyzing Indonesia Collision Accidents. TransNav, the International Journal on Marine Navigation and Safety of Sea Transportation, Vol. 14, No. 3, doi:10.12716/1001.14.03.30, pp. 751-759, 2020

Other publications of authors:

File downloaded 46 times

Important: TransNav.eu cookie usage
The TransNav.eu website uses certain cookies. A cookie is a text-only string of information that the TransNav.EU website transfers to the cookie file of the browser on your computer. Cookies allow the TransNav.eu website to perform properly and remember your browsing history. Cookies also help a website to arrange content to match your preferred interests more quickly. Cookies alone cannot be used to identify you.
Akceptuję pliki cookies z tej strony